Friday, April 11, 2008

Declaration of conversion

It's a step in the right direction, the intention is good, unfortunately the declaration by itself will not solve the problem.

The form is just another piece of paper prepared by Islamic religious authorities. A declaration by the pending convert is not enough, it doesn't ensure that the spouse/parents/guardian or next of kin is/are actually aware of the pending conversion - the potential convert can declared that he had informed the relevant relative but it may not be true.

Even if the form required signature(s) of the relevant relative, it can be forged.

The form is necessary but it need a safeguard mechanism - a special unit that is not under any religious bodies need to be set up to verify that the relevant relative have been informed.

The formation of the unit need to be done carefully. It must not be bias to any religion.


Gan's widow, when Gan’s body was taken away – pix from Hsu Darren blog


Malaysiakini

Gov't to act on Islamic conversion rows Apr 10, 08 5:41pm

The government today proposed new rules on converting to Islam, in a bid to prevent wrangles that have split families and incited racial tensions in this multicultural country.

"We are working on a law that non-Muslims who are converting to Islam must inform their spouse and family," Prime Minister Abdullah Ahmad Badawi said after meeting Islamic religious authorities.

"They will have to fill out a form and declare that they have informed their family of the pending conversion," he said.

The move follows a series of allegations of "body-snatching" by Islamic authorities, who have seized remains for burial according to Muslim rites, against the objections of non-Muslim family members.

The proposals are an olive branch to Malaysia's minority ethnic Chinese and Indians who are uneasy over rising "Islamisation" and have turned away from the government, which is dominated by Muslim Malays.

The coalition government's mis-handling of race issues is credited as one of the factors behind its drubbing in March 8 elections, when it lost a third of parliamentary seats and five states in its worst-ever results.

Clash between religions

Abdullah said there had been many cases where non-Muslims had converted to Islam quietly without informing their families.

"This has resulted in a clash between religions when the person dies and the Islamic authorities try to claim the body but are opposed by family members who were not informed of the conversion," he said.

"This has caused much ill-will among the various religions."

In the most recent case, an elderly ethnic Chinese man was buried as a Muslim in January after his Buddhist family lost a battle with Islamic authorities who said he had converted.

Police seized the body of Gan Eng For after his eldest son - himself a Muslim convert - said he had switched to the religion. Other family members said that was impossible because he was senile and paralysed from strokes.

In many instances the rows have been decided by Islamic syariah courts, where non-Muslim family members argue they do not get a fair hearing.

(AFP)


No comments: